Still they are bis for some classes, what is even you point xD Literally there are sooo many people who dont roll some classes due to the fact that they know that they cant get bis gear without pvping. Wether or not this new convoluted crap will make the game better is another thing entirely. The whole point is that PvP:ers need to stick to vers and the PvP-trinket set, plus now this scaling, and PvE:ers are dissuaded to get the PvP gear because it's not the highest possible ilvl in PvE. You seem very misinformed about the whole thing. It's just the best and most reliable %^&* for most 1-2 minute burst based specs. Many classes like fire mage will most likely still want Badge even at lower ilvl.
It's just gonna be scaled up quite a bit in PvP, and be capped at a 'real ilvl' lower than the highest PvE gear anywhere that's not PvP.
Pve items are similar I think, there was a post here on wowhead weeks ago about that specifically. PvP items are 6 levels lower or some jazz like that in pve. Ferocity is nerfed in pve and the other way around for pve gear in pvp.
